Loading...
Canada deserves to know.
Loading...
Tag
4 articles
In Canada, passing a law does not make it unchallengeable. Because the Constitution — including the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the division of powers between Parliament and the provinces — is the supreme law, courts can declare a statute invalid if it conflicts with the Constitution. A challenge typically begins when someone with standing (a person directly affected, or a public-interest litigant granted standing) sues, often after being charged under the law or directly harmed by it. The case starts in a trial court (a superior court of a province, or the Federal Court), where evidence is heard and a first ruling issued; it can then be appealed to the provincial Court of Appeal and, with permission (leave), to the Supreme Court of Canada, whose decision is final and binding nationwide. Governments can also skip the litigation route and ask a court directly for an advisory opinion through a "reference." If a court finds a law unconstitutional, its remedies range from "reading down" or "reading in" (narrowing or adding words to save the law) to striking it down in whole or in part, sometimes with a suspended declaration giving Parliament time to fix it. Two doctrines shape the whole process: section 1 of the Charter, which lets the government justify a rights limit as reasonable (the Oakes test), and section 33, the notwithstanding clause, which lets a legislature override certain Charter rulings. The result is a continuing dialogue between Parliament and the courts — laws this site tracks through the House are frequently tested, narrowed, or struck afterward in a courtroom.
The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms is Part I of the Constitution Act, 1982. It guarantees a defined set of rights against government action, grouped into categories: fundamental freedoms (s. 2 — conscience and religion, expression, peaceful assembly, association); democratic rights (ss. 3–5 — the right to vote, maximum five-year legislative terms, annual sittings); mobility rights (s. 6 — to enter, remain in, and leave Canada, and to move between provinces); legal rights (ss. 7–14 — life, liberty and security of the person; protection against unreasonable search and seizure, arbitrary detention; rights on arrest and at trial; protection against cruel and unusual punishment); equality rights (s. 15); official-language rights (ss. 16–22) and minority-language education rights (s. 23); plus interpretive and general provisions (ss. 25–34, including protections for Indigenous rights and multicultural heritage). Two structural clauses govern how the rights operate. Section 1 lets governments justify limits on rights if they are "reasonable" and "demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society" — the framework applied through the Oakes test. Section 33, the notwithstanding clause, lets Parliament or a legislature override certain Charter sections for renewable five-year periods (covered in depth in our notwithstanding-clause explainer). The Charter binds government, not private individuals, and the courts enforce it — they can strike down laws that violate it.
The Governor General is the federal representative of Canada's head of state (the King), appointed by the King on the Prime Minister's advice, conventionally for about five years. The office's constitutional functions include summoning, proroguing, and dissolving Parliament; granting royal assent to bills (the final step of every federal law); appointing the Prime Minister and, on the PM's advice, ministers, senators, and superior-court judges; signing orders-in-council; and serving as commander-in-chief. By constitutional convention, almost all of this is exercised on the advice of the Prime Minister who commands the confidence of the House of Commons — the GG's personal discretion is confined to the reserve powers, used in genuinely exceptional circumstances. The only federal exercise of a reserve power against a Prime Minister's advice remains the 1926 King-Byng affair, when Governor General Lord Byng refused Prime Minister Mackenzie King's request for dissolution months after an election, invited Arthur Meighen to govern instead, and watched Meighen's government fall within days — producing an election King won on the issue of the refusal itself. The episode is simultaneously the proof the reserve powers exist and the cautionary tale that keeps them sheathed: every Governor General since has granted every prime ministerial request, including the politically explosive 2008 prorogation.
Section 33 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms allows Parliament or a provincial legislature to expressly declare that a law operates "notwithstanding" certain Charter sections. The override applies to sections 2 (fundamental freedoms) and 7-15 (legal and equality rights). It does not apply to sections 3-5 (democratic rights), 6 (mobility), 16-23 (language and minority-language education), or 27-29 (other constitutional rights). The override lasts five years and is renewable. The clause was a key compromise that made the 1982 Charter possible — without it, several premiers would not have agreed to patriation.